On our very last international trip we returned to Italy, where — two years earlier — we had arranged to spend a year. After my wife Grace’s devastating metastasis, that year was reduced to a mere 2 weeks. But now we were back in our town in the Cilento, in Campania, 2 hours southeast of Naples, and then later in the village in Umbria where we’d stayed 9 years earlier. And finally, on our last two nights, with Grace struggling but then feeling well enough to take the bus from Maestre on the mainland, we reached Venice, which had been so beautiful in the past.
We strolled the canals with me trying not to pay attention to where we were. It was an incredible movie set with so many dilapidated, ramshackle and/or beautiful façades. So many buildings, what looked like luxurious rooms out of a midnight dream, free of the restrictions that, in these states, imagination overcomes.
Ah, dream-o, chemo. But when we merely edged into the busier and more touristic parts of town we at once saw a change that disgusted us both. It was as though we had come into a Disneyland-style shopping mall, designed in supposedly exquisite intimidating taste. We felt or were meant to feel that this was a playground for the rich that we ordinary types — ordinary but well-enough off to travel! — would feel compelled to, would feel ashamed not to imitate.
This seemed a kind of desecration. A World Heritage site, yes, but that was 9 years ago; now this was about greed and manipulation; beauty was sacrificed — as it had been long ago — at some obscure altar of business. As I quote — from myself, I guess — in more than one novel and screenplay, “To a businessman business is always a possibility.”
Well, haven’t attractive women always been made use of, hired to sell cars, booze and whatever else? And those are human beings. What’s so strange or horrifying about the sacrifice of a beautiful World Heritage site? Maybe just that it was new to us. Nine years ago there wasn’t this.
So, do what? Boycott? Lobby? Tell our friends, tell the TV? Or adjust our own mania? Is it really such spectacular news that “beauty is just one more commodity”? Are we not merely innocent but plumb out-of-it, unplugged from what’s been going on — apparently everywhere — all this time? Are we 20 years behind, lost and dreaming in our own happy beautiful tiny world? A world of love, joy and struggle. But away from the cool hard reality that has developed meanwhile outside…
In the end we ate in a touristy restaurant by the Rialto Bridge. The food, to be generous, was nothing special and afterward we felt ripped off. But one of us (I forget which) had a view of the scene with the bridge and the other had a neck-craning view of the same.
Next day, our last day out of the country, Grace felt better an hour earlier than the day before. We took the vaporetto to San Marcos, were disgusted by the prices of gelato, by the price of sitting down for even a lemonade — and in general altogether disgusted. We headed away, had a gelato to go, walked and walked, and on my stepson’s advice headed up north to Canareggio, which was much less touristy, and finally to the old Jewish Ghetto. And we found ourselves a little quiet restaurant on an alley, just what we’d half-wanted the night before. There we ate and dawdled and probably toasted our last night abroad together, then or ever. We strolled back toward Piazzale Roma, crossed a footbridge and found our bus…
© Jerry Kurtz
wasn’t venice always the whore or should I say the pimp for big business
But hasn’t intimidating the non-elite, halfway regular people gotten more insidious?
hi, jerry. share a lot of your thoughts about over-touristed world sites. we’ve experienced similar feelings in prague, venice, paris, costa rica, ibiza, athens, etc. getting off the beaten track helps us get through it all. glad to see you’re writing again on-site. — all best, bernie
Jerry,
I have been going to Venice for over 40 years and always enjoy it. Venice has been ripping off tourists for centuries and has it down to a science – nevertheless, its attractions are worth it and you can run into some delightful experiences when you get away from the main tourist route. I’m glad you and Grace found a little of that near the Ghetto area on your last day there. I have not experienced Bernie’s luck off the beaten track in Athens in several stays there. All the best to you.
Bob
Back in 2002 I was dumbfounded by Venice — at once I found it the most beautiful city I’d seen, dislodging Vienna and Zürich. If we’d been going for dozens of decades like you and Bernie, maybe we’d have been prepared…
Dear Jerry ~
So good to hear your musings about what I’m guessing was your last Trip abroad with your beloved Grace.
The time I visited Venice was in another Era ~ Looking back, everything seemed so different then – so innocent …. It was in the Spring of 1959 – and April indeed blessed us with proverbial Showers, such that my most vivid memory (and constant thought at that moment) was “How can I enjoy the Romance of this unique and truly Legendary Spot, so famously pronounced by every 18th Century Sonnet and 20th Century Travel Enticement, when amidst the pouring rain and the warm day’s Sewer Stench that rose prolificly from the grungy Cannals, I was fighting to maintain my Husband’s pace with the most shallow of breaths possible!”
It’s great to see you’re writing again.
Hugs, Anne
Great to hear from you, Anne. I’m hoping that this most recent advance of Ugliness — I suspect there’s been a back-and-forth with Beauty for centuries — will be beaten back again. Or washed back by those pouring rains. I don’t really mind the stench, it’s a reminder…
Enjoyed reading the Venice tirade….Baltimore, thankfully, remains largely undiscovered by tourists. And those who do come rarely venture further than HarbourPlace.
And Balto. is a great place to visit! Down home, full of local color and great food. Very low on the snob index…